{
  "schema_version": "figures_of_speech_source_sidecar_preview_v1",
  "source_note": "Generated from final CSV/JSON source state for verification and future builder input. This is not verified against any pre-existing live-site sidecar schema.",
  "figure": {
    "figure_id": "FOS_0341",
    "figure_name": "Diatribe / Objection and Response",
    "technical_name": "Diatribe",
    "alternate_names": "Objection and answer; imagined interlocutor; rhetorical objector",
    "page_slug": "diatribe-objection-and-response",
    "reader_category": "Argument / Disputation",
    "bullinger_class": "Rhetorical discourse form / objection and reply",
    "simple_definition": "Diatribe answers an imagined objection so the argument can expose false reasoning and press the truth more clearly.",
    "technical_definition": "Diatribe is a disputational speech form in which the writer or speaker introduces an objection, question, or imagined interlocutor and then answers it to advance the argument.",
    "source_hint": "Bible-study taxonomy extension; verify each example because not every question-answer sequence is a formal diatribe.",
    "canonical_url": "https://ai-bible-commentary.com/figures-of-speech-in-the-bible/diatribe-objection-and-response/",
    "json_sidecar_path": "/data/figures-of-speech/diatribe-objection-and-response.json",
    "publication_status": "style_matched_draft_v17",
    "page_status": "draft-normalized"
  },
  "scripture_examples": [
    {
      "example_id": "EX17_1467",
      "figure_id": "FOS_0341",
      "figure_name": "Diatribe / Objection and Response",
      "page_slug": "diatribe-objection-and-response",
      "reference": "Mal. 1:2",
      "text_excerpt_or_summary": "Wherein hast thou loved us?",
      "explanation": "The prophet states Israel's implied objection and answers it to expose covenant ingratitude.",
      "certainty": "probable",
      "source": "Draft-normalized biblical rhetoric dataset",
      "source_section": "Wave 17 disputation, witness, and commissioning forms",
      "include_on_page": "yes",
      "representative": "yes",
      "review_notes": "Verify against final site Bible text stream, source taxonomy, and original-language/context review before publication.",
      "review_status": "draft-normalized"
    },
    {
      "example_id": "EX17_1468",
      "figure_id": "FOS_0341",
      "figure_name": "Diatribe / Objection and Response",
      "page_slug": "diatribe-objection-and-response",
      "reference": "Rom. 3:1-9",
      "text_excerpt_or_summary": "What advantage then hath the Jew?",
      "explanation": "Paul raises anticipated objections and answers them to clarify guilt, privilege, and God's righteousness.",
      "certainty": "certain",
      "source": "Draft-normalized biblical rhetoric dataset",
      "source_section": "Wave 17 disputation, witness, and commissioning forms",
      "include_on_page": "yes",
      "representative": "no",
      "review_notes": "Verify against final site Bible text stream, source taxonomy, and original-language/context review before publication.",
      "review_status": "draft-normalized"
    },
    {
      "example_id": "EX17_1469",
      "figure_id": "FOS_0341",
      "figure_name": "Diatribe / Objection and Response",
      "page_slug": "diatribe-objection-and-response",
      "reference": "Rom. 6:1-2",
      "text_excerpt_or_summary": "Shall we continue in sin? God forbid.",
      "explanation": "An imagined objection misuses grace; Paul rejects it and reasons from union with Christ.",
      "certainty": "certain",
      "source": "Draft-normalized biblical rhetoric dataset",
      "source_section": "Wave 17 disputation, witness, and commissioning forms",
      "include_on_page": "yes",
      "representative": "no",
      "review_notes": "Verify against final site Bible text stream, source taxonomy, and original-language/context review before publication.",
      "review_status": "draft-normalized"
    },
    {
      "example_id": "EX17_1470",
      "figure_id": "FOS_0341",
      "figure_name": "Diatribe / Objection and Response",
      "page_slug": "diatribe-objection-and-response",
      "reference": "Rom. 6:15",
      "text_excerpt_or_summary": "Shall we sin, because we are not under law?",
      "explanation": "Paul anticipates antinomian misuse of grace and denies it sharply.",
      "certainty": "certain",
      "source": "Draft-normalized biblical rhetoric dataset",
      "source_section": "Wave 17 disputation, witness, and commissioning forms",
      "include_on_page": "yes",
      "representative": "no",
      "review_notes": "Verify against final site Bible text stream, source taxonomy, and original-language/context review before publication.",
      "review_status": "draft-normalized"
    },
    {
      "example_id": "EX17_1471",
      "figure_id": "FOS_0341",
      "figure_name": "Diatribe / Objection and Response",
      "page_slug": "diatribe-objection-and-response",
      "reference": "Rom. 7:7",
      "text_excerpt_or_summary": "Is the law sin? God forbid.",
      "explanation": "The question anticipates a false conclusion and lets Paul explain the law's revelatory role.",
      "certainty": "certain",
      "source": "Draft-normalized biblical rhetoric dataset",
      "source_section": "Wave 17 disputation, witness, and commissioning forms",
      "include_on_page": "yes",
      "representative": "no",
      "review_notes": "Verify against final site Bible text stream, source taxonomy, and original-language/context review before publication.",
      "review_status": "draft-normalized"
    },
    {
      "example_id": "EX17_1472",
      "figure_id": "FOS_0341",
      "figure_name": "Diatribe / Objection and Response",
      "page_slug": "diatribe-objection-and-response",
      "reference": "Rom. 9:14",
      "text_excerpt_or_summary": "Is there unrighteousness with God?",
      "explanation": "Paul raises and answers a theological objection about God's justice.",
      "certainty": "certain",
      "source": "Draft-normalized biblical rhetoric dataset",
      "source_section": "Wave 17 disputation, witness, and commissioning forms",
      "include_on_page": "yes",
      "representative": "no",
      "review_notes": "Verify against final site Bible text stream, source taxonomy, and original-language/context review before publication.",
      "review_status": "draft-normalized"
    },
    {
      "example_id": "EX17_1473",
      "figure_id": "FOS_0341",
      "figure_name": "Diatribe / Objection and Response",
      "page_slug": "diatribe-objection-and-response",
      "reference": "Rom. 9:19",
      "text_excerpt_or_summary": "Why doth he yet find fault?",
      "explanation": "The imagined objector challenges divine sovereignty and accountability; Paul answers by reasserting creaturely humility.",
      "certainty": "certain",
      "source": "Draft-normalized biblical rhetoric dataset",
      "source_section": "Wave 17 disputation, witness, and commissioning forms",
      "include_on_page": "yes",
      "representative": "no",
      "review_notes": "Verify against final site Bible text stream, source taxonomy, and original-language/context review before publication.",
      "review_status": "draft-normalized"
    },
    {
      "example_id": "EX17_1474",
      "figure_id": "FOS_0341",
      "figure_name": "Diatribe / Objection and Response",
      "page_slug": "diatribe-objection-and-response",
      "reference": "Rom. 11:1",
      "text_excerpt_or_summary": "Hath God cast away his people?",
      "explanation": "Paul introduces a possible objection to Israel's place in God's plan and answers it from Scripture and remnant theology.",
      "certainty": "certain",
      "source": "Draft-normalized biblical rhetoric dataset",
      "source_section": "Wave 17 disputation, witness, and commissioning forms",
      "include_on_page": "yes",
      "representative": "no",
      "review_notes": "Verify against final site Bible text stream, source taxonomy, and original-language/context review before publication.",
      "review_status": "draft-normalized"
    },
    {
      "example_id": "EX17_1475",
      "figure_id": "FOS_0341",
      "figure_name": "Diatribe / Objection and Response",
      "page_slug": "diatribe-objection-and-response",
      "reference": "1 Cor. 15:35",
      "text_excerpt_or_summary": "How are the dead raised up?",
      "explanation": "Paul introduces an objector's question so he can answer with seed, body, and resurrection analogies.",
      "certainty": "certain",
      "source": "Draft-normalized biblical rhetoric dataset",
      "source_section": "Wave 17 disputation, witness, and commissioning forms",
      "include_on_page": "yes",
      "representative": "no",
      "review_notes": "Verify against final site Bible text stream, source taxonomy, and original-language/context review before publication.",
      "review_status": "draft-normalized"
    },
    {
      "example_id": "EX17_1476",
      "figure_id": "FOS_0341",
      "figure_name": "Diatribe / Objection and Response",
      "page_slug": "diatribe-objection-and-response",
      "reference": "Jas. 2:18",
      "text_excerpt_or_summary": "Yea, a man may say...",
      "explanation": "James introduces an imagined claim to expose the impossibility of separating genuine faith from works.",
      "certainty": "probable",
      "source": "Draft-normalized biblical rhetoric dataset",
      "source_section": "Wave 17 disputation, witness, and commissioning forms",
      "include_on_page": "yes",
      "representative": "no",
      "review_notes": "Verify against final site Bible text stream, source taxonomy, and original-language/context review before publication.",
      "review_status": "draft-normalized"
    }
  ],
  "canonical_url": "https://ai-bible-commentary.com/figures-of-speech-in-the-bible/diatribe-objection-and-response/",
  "json_sidecar_path": "/data/figures-of-speech/diatribe-objection-and-response.json",
  "public_build": {
    "build_id": "figures_of_speech_wave46_public_pages_and_json_v1",
    "build_time_utc": "2026-05-25T16:37:54+00:00",
    "html_path": "/figures-of-speech-in-the-bible/diatribe-objection-and-response/index.html",
    "source_of_truth": "Wave 46 CSV/JSON source state"
  }
}